NCWP Publications
Law Enforcement Jobs
In the News
Related Links
NCWP Store
Becoming an Officer
Women in Policing History
About Us
About NCWP
About Feminist Majority Foundation
Donate to the Feminist Majority Foundation
Other FMF Projects


Federal Appeals Court Rules Wisconsin Abortion Law Unconstitutional

The 7th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled on Monday that the hospital admitting requirement for Wisconsin abortion providers is unconstitutional.

The scathing 2-1 ruling states that this kind of targeted restriction on abortion providers is unconstitutional because it lacks any basis to suggest that it improves safety at clinics. In his decision, Judge Richard Posner (a Reagan appointee) dismantles the argument for implementing onerous anti-abortion laws under the guise of protecting women's health:
"Some of them proceed indirectly, seeking to discourage abortions by making it more difficult for women to obtain them. They may do this in the name of protecting the health of women who have abortions, yet as in this case the specific measures they support may do little or nothing for health, but rather strew impediments to abortion."

These laws, known broadly as targeted regulation of abortion providers (TRAP laws), have become common practice for conservative lawmakers looking to restrict abortion access without banning the procedure outright. Posner's opinion reinforces that the Wisconsin law "cannot be taken seriously as a measure to improve women's health," adding that the evidence of health benefits for women is "nonexistent."

A similar case will be heard by the Supreme Court next year. Whole Woman's Health v. Cole challenges two provisions of Texas' omnibus abortion law, known as HB2. The first provision, which has already forced more than half of the clinics in the state to close, requires providers to secure hospital admitting privileges. The second provision forces clinics to fulfill costly, medically unnecessary ambulatory surgical center (ASC) requirements. Should the Supreme Court rule that requiring hospital admitting privileges is legal, the 7th Circuit Court ruling would be overturned.

Feminist.org: Your daily source for the feminist perspective on national and global events. Media Resources: Jezebel 11/24/15, US Court of Appeals Decision 11/23/15; Feminist Newswire 11/13/15



Also In the News

11/25/2015 FMF Joins the Global 16 Days of Activism Against Gender-Based Violence

11/25/2015 Afghan Women Launch 16 Days of Activism Against Gender-Based Violence

11/25/2015 Federal Appeals Court Rules Wisconsin Abortion Law Unconstitutional




| About Us | Search | Shop | Home

Copyright 2001-2013 Feminist Majority Foundation's National Center for Women and Policing